• home
  • index of films
    • index of films featuring maps
    • index of films featuring photography
    • bibliography
  • blogs
    • maps in films
    • choses vues - things seen
    • l'Escalographe
    • the BlowUp moment
  • how to map a film
    • the first maps >
      • Some Maps in Gance's Napoléon
  • Paris
    • 1890s-1909 >
      • firemen in Paris, 1896
      • La Villette c.1896-97
      • Hatot-Breteau 1897
      • Place de l'Opéra
      • Paris 1900
      • French Cancan >
        • the real Paquerette >
          • Paquerettes
      • Alice Guy - Paris locations >
        • Alice Guy in the brothel ...
      • a dangerous street corner
      • Capellani in Paris
      • La Fille du faux-monnayeur
    • 1910-1929 >
      • a gateway out of Paris c.1910
      • L'Enfant de Paris (narrative of an identification)
      • Fantomas Over Paris: episode 1 >
        • Fantomas Over Paris: episode 2 >
          • Fantomas Over Paris: episode 3 >
            • Fantomas Over Paris: episode 4 >
              • Fantomas Over Belgium
      • One Place, Three Films: Fantomas and the French New Wave
      • a staircase in Belleville
      • Vampires Over Paris >
        • Les Vampires 1
        • Les Vampires 2
        • Les Vampires 3
        • Les Vampires 4
        • Les Vampires 5
        • Les Vampires 6
        • Les Vampires, 7
        • Les Vampires 8
        • Les Vampires 9
        • Les Vampires 10
      • Irma Vep posts a letter
      • Inside-Outside: space and light in Judex
      • L'Affaire Barsac
      • neon Paris c.1913
      • electric nights in Paris (and Berlin)
    • 1930-1959 >
      • Quai des Orfèvres
      • Olivia - Audry - 1951
      • Paris Noir: Becker, Dassin, Melville
      • the persistence of graffiti: Paris c.1952
      • Du rififi chez les hommes - reading topotropically >
        • Du rififi chez les hommes - locations identified
      • Het Parijs van Le Ballon rouge
    • the New Wave and after >
      • New Wave places >
        • New Wave Paris >
          • New Wave Newness: architecture in Paris
          • Eric Rohmer in the rue de la Huchette, c.1956
          • Les 400 coups: Paris locations >
            • Baisers volés
          • 'New York Herald Tribune' - Parrish and Godard on the rue de Berri >
            • A bout de souffle (narrative of an identification)
          • the Grisbi connection: Chabrol and Becker
          • Les Bonnes Femmes: sequence by sequence
          • Une femme est une femme: the places documented
          • the boulevard des Italiens
          • Jules et Jim: Paris configured
          • the place of cinema: cinema as location in Vivre sa vie
          • Godard and Melville: the view from the rue Jenner >
            • Melville: more views from the rue Jenner
          • the New Wave in Pigalle c.1963
          • La Peau douce - displaced places
          • Le Bonheur 1965
          • Paris vu par
          • Masculin Féminin
          • The Topography of La Guerre est finie
        • France
      • Le Samourai: places and maps >
        • Un flic: art and artifice
      • Bresson in Paris - Pickpocket
      • Bresson 69-71
      • Every Revolution
      • statues in Godard and Duras
      • Holy Motors >
        • Holy Motors - notes
    • banlieues >
      • Le Canal de Ourcq
      • Ville d'Avray en 1903
      • Three filmmakers in Romainville
      • filmmaking in the Fontainebleau forest
      • Feuillade's lonely villas
      • anarchists in the suburbs c.1912
      • One Church Two Cemeteries: Clouzot and Chabrol at Montfort L'Amaury
      • Feuilladian Franju - Les Yeux sans visage
      • country houses and suburban villas
      • banlieue locations in L'Amour existe
      • the Landru Villa
      • 1 place 2 filmmakers: Rivette & Chabrol in Ermenonville
      • Céline et Julie: what's the address of that house?
      • cinemas in La Petite Voleuse
    • The Stairs: Paris
  • London
    • 1890s-1920s >
      • Lumiere London >
        • Lumière London, bis
      • Robert Paul in London: tour guide and film maker
      • Ultus in Isleworth
      • Cocaine 1922
      • Fu Manchu 1923
    • London Locations >
      • Piccadilly Circus >
        • Piccadilly Circus in films
        • Piccadilly Circus in art
        • Piccadilly Circus in postcards
        • Piccadilly Circus photographed
        • Piccadilly Circus: invisible things
      • Muswell Hill
      • the Arsenal Stadium mysteries
      • Brentford streets on screen
    • the locality of London studios >
      • Early Ealing
      • straight out of Whetstone
      • Walthamstow's studios
    • Sherlock Holmes >
      • some Baker Street irregularities
      • an American Sherlock in London
    • Sojourners + Cosmopolitans >
      • London in French Film >
        • Rififi in London
        • London in London River
      • maps in krimis
      • Kriminal (1966)
      • Kaurismaki's London c. 1989
    • places in Face
  • Geneva
    • Swiss New Wave - shared-world practice
    • Geneva in Swiss New Wave films >
      • SNW Geneva: collective housing
      • SNW Geneva: villas
      • SNW Geneva: bowlings + piscines
    • The Chronology of Le Petit Soldat
    • La Lune avec les dents (Michel Soutter 1966)
    • L'Inconnu de Shandigor (J.-L. Roy 1967)
  • signage, etc.
  • studios, etc.
    • Eclair
    • Eclipse
    • Gaumont >
      • Cité Elgé locations
    • Lumière
    • Lux
    • Pathé >
      • Where's Max >
        • when Harry met Max, and where
        • Max takes the train
      • Bébé victime d'une erreur...
      • Montreuil in Pathe films
      • Pathé police stations
      • Pathé filmmaking in Nice c. 1908
    • studios & the local >
      • Ealing >
        • Kind Hearts and Coronets: suburbia and other places
        • the view from Ealing
  • my local filmmaker
    • The Unfortunate Policeman >
      • Buy Your Own Cherries >
        • The Medium Exposed >
          • The ? Motorist >
            • The Fatal Hand >
              • A Little Bit of Cloth
              • Blind Man's Bluff >
                • Bill Sikes Up-To-Date
    • Walter Booth in Muswell Hill
  • my local cinemas
  • favourites
    • Agnès Varda >
      • Cleo 5-7 - Time
      • Sans toit ni loi >
        • Sans toit ni loi - the 12 tracking shots
        • Mona's postcard collection
    • Alice Guy >
      • Alice Guy + JLG
    • Chris Marker
    • Jacques Rivette >
      • a map of Out 1
      • Le Pont du Nord: locations identified >
        • topographical telescoping in Le Pont du Nord
        • Le Pont du Nord (narrative of an identification)
    • J.-L. Godard >
      • Godardiana
      • A bout de souffle: footnotes to the film >
        • A bout de souffle - the cast list
        • A bout de souffle in colour
      • photographs in Le Petit Soldat
      • Bande à part
      • Paintings in Pierrot le fou
      • sculptures in Made in USA
      • Les Fins de Godard
      • Week End - time, place and cars
      • Bukowski in Sauve qui peut (la vie)
      • Life magazine + Hdc
    • J.-P. Melville
    • Louis Feuillade
    • Max Linder
    • Robert Paul
  • cine-tourists
    • a German tourist in Paris: Le Silence de la mer
    • an American tourist in Paris
    • History Lessons in Rome
  • Nouvelle Vague
    • New Wave Christmas
    • the New Wave and modern art >
      • New Wave Braque
      • New Wave Chagall
      • New Wave Klee
      • New Wave Manet
      • New Wave Miro
      • New Wave Modigliani
      • New Wave Picasso
      • Pierre Alechinsky in Le Joli Mai (1963)
    • New Wave cameos
    • Attal et Zardi
    • Le Signe du Lion: six small things
    • New Wave films in New Wave films
    • Cahiers du Cinéma on screen
  • other things
    • assorted stamps
    • Maps in Books
    • the topographies of La Fille aux yeux d'or
    • place-time in Thérèse Raquin
    • photography >
      • 10 photographs by Brassaï in 3 Paris dancehalls >
        • painters in the rue Blomet
      • Gisèle Freund in Paris >
        • Gisèle Freund in Histoire(s) du cinéma
      • Godard's Histoire(s): photographs of women
      • the photographer as photographer: André Dino with Tati, Truffaut and Chabrol
      • some Simenon book covers
      • films playing at the Moulin Rouge
    • building sites >
      • a building site and some buildings, c.1961 >
        • Jean Ginsberg
      • 93 - Seine Saint Denis: HLM, cités, grands ensembles >
        • 93 - Seine Saint Denis: Aubervilliers to Bondy
        • 93 - Seine Saint Denis: Drancy to l'île Saint Denis
        • 93 - Seine Saint Denis: La Courneuve to Saint Ouen
        • 93 - Seine Saint Denis: Sevran to Villepinte
      • Chateau Gaillard
      • Euston Station
    • investigations >
      • A Remarkable Journey in Zigoto's New Motor-Car - 1912
      • the Hotel Bristol enigma
    • news >
      • French news
      • news from England
      • news from the U.S.
    • a picture of great significance
    • A Girl and a Gun >
      • Griffith, Shadowland, May 1922
  • efc - places
  • contact details
    • directories
    • address books
    • hotel registers
    • envelopes and postcards
    • telegrams
  • family, locality
    • a Succession of Edwards
    • Henri Grieshaber - architecte chaudefonnier
  • about this site
  • Publications
The Cine-Tourist
all you need is...
Picture


All over the internet and in scholarly works, the phrase 'all you need to make a movie is a girl and a gun' is  attributed to Jean-Luc Godard, and that despite his insistence that 'c'est Griffith qui a dit ça, ce n'est pas moi' ('it was Griffith who said that, not me').

Godard seems to have first attributed the phrase to Griffith in 1964, in the trade-press spread announcing his forthcoming film Bande à part
:
'What do filmgoers want?' Griffith asked. 'A girl and a gun'. It's to meet their wishes that I have made, and that Columbia will distribute, Bande à part, a sure-fire story that will sell a lot of tickets.
Picture
Bande à part (1964)
Commentators who picked up on Godard's phrase initially preserved the attribution, but in 1966, in The New Republic, Pauline Kael's piece 'Godard among the Gangsters' left Griffith out of the equation: 'Jean-Luc Godard intended to give the public what it wanted. His next film was going to be about a girl and a gun - "a sure-fire story which will sell lots of tickets".' 

Kael reproduced this piece in her 1968 book Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, a title that says more or less the same thing that Griffith had, if more graphically.

The same idea informed Claude Lelouch's choice of title in 1965 when he made Une fille et des fusils ('a girl and some rifles'), a Bande à part  homage-cum-pastiche that featured girls and guns, as well as a close up of a newspaper with an advert for Bande à part:
Picture
Picture
Godard himself followed Bande à part with other films featuring girls and guns, e.g. Alphaville (1965):
Picture
Pierrot le fou (1965):
Picture
Made in USA (1966):
Picture
And La Chinoise (1967):
Picture
In the 1978 lectures that would lead to his  'Introduction to a True History of Cinema and Television' (now available in Timothy Barnard's brilliant new translation), Godard compared Made in USA with Bande à part and returned to the phrase:

 'Griffith said: "What is cinema? A girl and a gun". I believed in that.' 

The question has changed from 'What do filmgoers want?' to 'What is cinema?' The latter question, if indissolubly Bazinian, is now also, for Godard, Griffithian. It is Godardian too, of course. In 1952 Godard had published an essay with that title, and in another offshoot of the Montreal lectures, his Histoire(s) du cinéma (1988-1998), the phrase is a leitmotif:
Picture
Picture
These instances are from parts 3A and 3B of Histoire(s) du cinéma. In 1A Griffith is discussed, and we find there the phrase attributed to him by Godard  in 1978 as an answer to the question above. The constituent parts of the phrase appear first:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Behind 'A GUN' is an image from Griffith's 1911 film The Lonedale Operator, as if attributing the phrase ('c'est Griffith qui a dit ça').  The other three images are Chaplin with a camera, a group of unidentified women in swimwear and Mauritz Stiller directing Greta Garbo in  The Temptress (1926). When the phrase first appears in complete form, it is over Stiller - note that Godard has cut Garbo out of the picture:
Picture
Picture
The photograph of Stiller directing alternates with one of Dorothy Lamour, as if she is replacing Garbo, as if a film is a gun and just any girl:
Picture
The Stiller/Lamour pairing is replaced with plain titles emphasising the 'AND' of the phrase:
The phrase doesn't appear again, and is signed off with an image from another Griffith film, The Unseen Enemy (1912). This famous framing of the Gish sisters is reframed to isolate Lillian in close up:
Picture
Picture
This refers to the legend that Griffith invented the close up. More obliquely, this section refers to Griffith's invention of cross-cutting by alternating the Gish sisters with an image taken from a pornographic film (unidentified, I think):
Picture
Picture
For a detailed reading of this passage, see Jean-Louis Leutrat's 'Retour sur Histoire(s), 5', in Trafic 75 (2010).

Truffaut's La Nuit américaine (1973)  features both girl and gun:
Picture
Picture
In the film's dedication Truffaut had used the image of the Gish sisters from The Unseen Enemy:
Picture
Picture
It was in 2001, in a discussion with Jacques Rancière and Charles Tesson (Cahiers du cinéma 557) that Godard reaffirmed the attribution of the phrase to Griffith rather than to himself. 

The question remains: did Griffith actually say it, and if so when, and where?

The answer is yes. In volume 4 of his Histoire générale du cinéma, Georges Sadoul quotes Griffith, from an interview, on film subjects and  the filmgoing public:

Je n'entrevois avant très longtemps aucune possibilité de se lancer dans des thèmes serrant de près la réalité: le public ne le permettrait pas. Ce qu'il lui faut, c'est a gun and a girl.

I foresee no possibility of venturing into themes showing a closer view of reality for a long time to come. The public itself will not have it. What it wants is a gun and a girl.

Sadoul goes on to say that Griffith resigned himself to giving the public what it wanted with the crime thriller One Exciting Night (1922):
Picture
Picture
(I haven't been able to see this film to know if there is actually a conjunction of girl and gun.)

Godard could have read the phrase in Sadoul's history, then, but not until 1974, when this volume of the Histoire générale du cinéma was first published - posthumously (Sadoul died in 1967). I have looked to see if Sadoul refers to this interview in any of his earlier works (Sadoul did recycle material), but I haven't found it mentioned by him elsewhere. Sadoul's source is an issue of Delluc's film magazine Cinéa
, from May 1922:
Picture
Picture
Picture
As Sadoul signals, this is a translation of parts of an interview with Griffith conducted by Frederick James Smith for the American magazine Shadowland, also May 1922. I haven't yet come across the original text of the interview to know exactly what Griffith said [update: see the end of this post for the Griffith interview], but here as compensation is the charming cover of that issue:
Picture
We could imagine that Godard found the interview with Griffith while flicking through dusty back copies of Cinéa or Shadowland in some dingy archive, but I suspect the source was some more accessible intermediary. We have established that it's probably not Sadoul, but the phrase was well-known to others. René Clair uses it in a speech on the Art of Cinema given in Geneva in 1967:

The public's tastes change but what attracts it most often is what our master D.W. Griffith defined thus, more than forty years ago: 'A girl and a gun', that is, eroticism and violence.
Clair featured girls and guns  in his films from the outset. Here, from 1926, is Dolly Davis in Le Voyage Imaginaire:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
And this is Sandra Milovanoff in La Proie du vent (1927):
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
But the best 'girl and a gun' combination in Clair's oeuvre is a film he conceived but didn't direct, Augusto Genina's Prix de beauté (1930) - Louise Brooks is the girl:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Here is a later instance, Dany Carrel in Clair's Porte des Lilas (1957):
Picture
Picture


Clair uses the phrase again in his 1970 book Cinéma d'hier, cinéma d'aujourd'hui. He might have got it from Godard's 1964 publicity spread, but I don't think so. Perhaps he is drawing on his memories as a 23-year-old cinephile reading the latest issue of Cinéa or Shadowland, or perhaps there was a publication, sometime in the  '50s say, that put the Griffith interview back into circulation but which hasn't yet been digitised for Gallica, Google Books or the Internet Archive (my usual sources).


If I find the missing link I'll update this post, and If I get hold of the English text of Griffith's interview I'll add it.


UPDATES:
​

If Clair is Godard's source, this is the most likely missing link, Clair's response to a  questionnaire on censorship and eroticism, for a special issue on love (Cahiers du Cinéma 42, décembre 1954), p.54:
Picture
When Griffith spoke of 'a girl and a gun', he was defining what it was that drew vulgar attention to the screen.

A strong candidate for the role of intermediary is the Belgian photographer and poet Paul Nougé (1895-1967), who referrred to Griffith's comment in his 'Introduction au cinéma', a lecture given in 1925 in Brussels, published in 1955 in the journal Les Lèvres nues and again in his book Histoire de ne pas rire (1956). Here is the context in which he used the phrase, from the 1980 republication of the book (p.35):

Picture
'As for the public, it plays its usual role, which is to impose its sentimental routine on those whom it considers, not entirely wrongly, to be its suppliers of pleasure. The public demands, said Griffith, a girl and a gun. That is enough to ensure that it gets them.'


Godard might have read this in the 1956 book and remembered it when he was publicising Bande à part in 1964.

Here are two examples of Nougé's work as a photographer:
Picture
Picture
For other photographs see here, and for Magritte's 1927 portrait of Nougé see here.


Thanks to the efforts of James Prochnik, I have obtained a copy of the text in which Sadoul and others found Griffith's  remark.  The interview is very illuminating, and can be read in full here. The section that concerns us is particularly interesting because it points to an earlier moment when Griffith made the remark: 
Picture
It goes without saying that I should like to know when Griffith first proposed this recipe for film popularity. It may take a while, but further updates will follow. 



Picture

footnote


Gustav Deutsch's 2009 archival piece Film ist a Girl & a Gun juxtaposes women and firearms through montage but only twice shows them combined in the same shot. The first is Dickson's 1894 film of Annie Oakley, the second I do not recognise:
Picture
Picture
Picture